shape
shape
shape
shape
shape
shape
Milos Gvozdenovic / 9 October 2019

Potential for Increased Dividends Based on Recent Appellate Decision

A recent appellate decision handed down by the United States District Court in the Eastern District of Michigan provides some good news for unsecured creditors seeking larger dividends in Chapter 13 cases.  The court affirmed a lower court ruling, in which it was determined “that Debtors’ voluntary post-petition contributions to a 401(k) account are part of disposable income.”  See Penfound v. Ruskin, Case No. 18-13333, 2019 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 160353 (E.D. Mich. Sept. 20, 2019) at 11.

 A Chapter 13 Debtor is under an obligation to commit all of their disposable income to their Chapter 13 plan as indicated in 11 U.S.C. § 1325.  The code section simply defines disposable income as the “current monthly income received by the Debtor.”  11 U.S.C. § 1325(b)(2).  There are explicit exemptions within the code for income that does not qualify as disposable income. Id. The code section also allows “reasonably necessary” expenses to be deducted from that income. Id. Anything remaining is committed to the Debtor’s Chapter 13 plan and distributed to creditors. Generally, the larger the disposable income amount, the more money that will be paid to unsecured creditors. 

The court in Pendfound relied heavily on the 6th Circuit decision in In Re Seafort, 669 F.3d. 662 (6th Cir. 2012).  The issue on appeal in Seafort was whether “the income that becomes available after the debtors have fully repaid their 401(k) loans … is ‘projected disposable income’ to be paid to the unsecured creditors.”  In Re Seafort, 669 F.3d. 662 (6th Cir. 2012) at 663.  The court in Seafort held that “post-petition income that becomes available to debtors after their 401(k) loans are fully repaid is known as ‘projected disposable income’ and must be turned over to the trustee for distribution to unsecured creditors.”  Id.  Seafort did not specifically address the issue of voluntary retirement contributions as disposable income in a Chapter 13, but it was addressed by the court within the footnotes of the case.  Penfound v. Ruskin, Case No. 18-13333, 2019 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 160353 (E.D. Mich. Sept. 20, 2019) at 10.  Although footnotes are not binding, the court in Pendfound found them to be heavily persuasive and felt that the 6th Circuit clearly “indicated its position on the issue.”  Id. at 10-11.

 As a result of the appellate court’s decision in this case, the original confirmation order in the Debtors’ Chapter 13 was upheld.  The Debtors were not allowed to voluntarily contribute to their 401(k) plan during the pendency of the Chapter 13 and their bi-weekly payments increased from $513.30 to $1,147.92.  Id. at 3.  This would result in an estimated net increase to unsecured creditors in the amount of $82,000. Id. at 2.  Hopefully, this is a trend we will continue to see across other districts and Debtors will be prohibited from reaping the benefits of padding their retirement savings at the expense of their creditors. 

Related News

Alerts / 9 October 2019

Ohio Recording Fees to Increase Statewide - Effective October 17, 2019

Ohio's 2,602 page budget bill recently signed by the Governor, includes an increase in fees to be charged by Ohio's County Recorders, effective October 17, 2019, for recording real estate documents.
Read More
Alerts / 3 October 2019

Illinois Governor Signs the Consumer Fairness Act - Taking Effect on January 1, 2020

Illinois Governor J.B. Pritzker signed House Bill 88, known as the Consumer Fairness Act, which reduces the applicable interest rate and shortens the period a judgment creditor can enforce its consumer debt judgment.
Read More
Insights / 14 August 2019

Thieves Among Us

United States businesses lose an average of seven percent of their annual revenues to employee theft each year, according to statistics from Statistic Brain Research Institute. Estimates range from $20 to $50 billion, making it one of the most costly and widespread challenges faced in today's business world.
Read More